While the VMAs have historically inspired experimental–often questionable–hair and makeup choices, this year’s red carpet was uncharacteristically subdued. Kim campaigned to make fresh-out-the-shower waves a thing, Beyoncé showed us how highlighter works, and Naomi Campbell tried Pat McGrath’s new Lust 004 glitter lip look. Here, all the hair and makeup you’ll want to recreate IRL. Read more at elle.com